Rent going up? One company’s algorithm could be why

ProPublica is a Pulitzer Prize-winning investigative newsroom. Indication up for The Significant Tale publication to get stories like this one particular in your inbox.

On a summer season day previous calendar year, a group of true estate tech executives gathered at a conference corridor in Nashville to boast about just one of their company’s signature products: software package that uses a mysterious algorithm to enable landlords drive the highest possible rents on tenants.

“Never right before have we viewed these numbers,” explained Jay Parsons, a vice president of RealPage, as conventiongoers wandered by. Apartment rents had not long ago shot up by as a lot as 14.5 per cent, he reported in a video touting the company’s products and services. Turning to his colleague, Parsons asked: What job experienced the application performed?

“I assume it’s driving it, fairly truthfully,” answered Andrew Bowen, a further RealPage government. “As a assets supervisor, pretty couple of us would be inclined to really increase rents double digits within just a solitary month by undertaking it manually.”

The celebratory remarks were being additional than swagger. For several years, RealPage has marketed application that uses data analytics to advise everyday prices for open up models. House professionals throughout the United States have gushed about how the company’s algorithm boosts profits.

“The natural beauty of YieldStar is that it pushes you to go locations that you would not have gone if you weren’t applying it,” said Kortney Balas, director of profits administration at JVM Realty, referring to RealPage’s software package in a testimonial online video on the company’s web site.

The nation’s greatest property administration business, Greystar, observed that even in just one downturn, its buildings utilizing YieldStar “outperformed their markets by 4.8 p.c,” a important premium above competitors, RealPage explained in resources on its website. Greystar employs RealPage’s computer software to rate tens of hundreds of residences.

RealPage grew to become the nation’s dominant supplier of these lease-placing computer software soon after federal regulators authorised a controversial merger in 2017, a ProPublica investigation discovered, considerably growing the company’s affect above apartment charges. The transfer served the Texas-primarily based enterprise press the consumer foundation for its array of true estate tech expert services past 31,700 consumers.

The impression is stark in some marketplaces.

In 1 neighborhood in Seattle, ProPublica located, 70 p.c of residences were being overseen by just 10 assets administrators, every single single 1 of which utilised pricing software program marketed by RealPage.

To arrive at a advised rent, the application deploys an algorithm—a set of mathematical rules—to evaluate a trove of knowledge RealPage gathers from consumers, such as personal data on what close by competitors demand.

For tenants, the program upends the exercise of negotiating with apartment building team. RealPage discourages bargaining with renters and has even recommended that landlords in some conditions acknowledge a decrease occupancy amount in buy to increase rents and make much more cash.

Just one of the algorithm’s builders advised ProPublica that leasing agents had “too much empathy” compared to personal computer-produced pricing.

Apartment professionals can reject the software’s tips, but as quite a few as 90 percent are adopted, according to previous RealPage personnel.

The software’s design and style and growing reach have lifted inquiries between serious estate and authorized experts about no matter if RealPage has birthed a new kind of cartel that enables the nation’s most significant landlords to indirectly coordinate pricing, perhaps in violation of federal legislation.

Professionals say RealPage and its purchasers invite scrutiny from antitrust enforcers for numerous causes, like their use of private facts on what opponents cost in rent. In unique, RealPage’s development of do the job teams that meet privately and contain landlords who are or else rivals could be a purple flag of possible collusion, a former federal prosecutor said.

At a least, critics explained, the software’s algorithm may well be artificially inflating rents and stifling competition.

“Machines immediately study the only way to acquire is to force charges previously mentioned aggressive concentrations,” said College of Tennessee law professor Maurice Stucke, a previous prosecutor in the Justice Department’s antitrust division.

RealPage acknowledged that it feeds its clients’ interior hire info into its pricing software package, providing landlords an aggregated, anonymous seem at what their competition close by are charging.

A firm agent stated in an email that RealPage “uses aggregated market data from a wide range of resources in a lawfully compliant method.”

The corporation observed that landlords who use personnel to manually established selling prices “typically” perform telephone surveys to test competitors’ rents, which the corporation suggests could result in anti-aggressive actions.

“RealPage’s earnings management methods prioritize a property’s possess internal supply/demand dynamics about exterior elements these as competitors’ rents,” a organization statement said, “and therefore aid reduce the threat of collusion that could occur with manual pricing.”

The assertion stated RealPage’s computer software also will help avert rents from reaching unaffordable ranges since it detects drops in demand from customers, like those people that come about seasonally, and can react to them by decreasing rents.

RealPage did not make Parsons, Bowen, or the company’s present CEO, Dana Jones, available for interviews. Balas and a Greystar representative declined to remark on the history about YieldStar. The National Multifamily Housing Council, an market team, also declined to remark.

Proponents say the application is not distorting the marketplace. RealPage’s CEO advised buyers 5 years back that the business would not be big sufficient to damage competition even right after the merger. The CEO of one of YieldStar’s earliest consumers, Ric Campo of Camden Residence Have confidence in, informed ProPublica that the condominium current market in his company’s house city alone is so huge and varied that “it would be really hard to argue there was some variety of price repairing.”